When a control result is outside its limits at 8:00 A.M., there are two options for a lab: investigation prior to releasing patient results, or assuming it was a single occurrence. Quality Control (QC) in laboratories is what establishes the routine use of the first option. Quality control provides feedback regarding whether your tests are performing properly, allowing you to establish trust in the results provided to physicians and patients. This booklet addresses IQC, EQA, Westgard Rules, National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL) requirements and daily operations within Indian diagnostic laboratories.
What Is Laboratory Quality Control?
Quality control in laboratories includes all of those actions taken to determine if tests are accurate and precise, find mistakes prior to releasing data and demonstrate that tests produce consistent results. Quality control exists within a larger laboratory quality management system which includes training, documentation, equipment maintenance and auditing. Quality control provides protection against error however, it does not provide a guarantee.
Why Is Quality Control Important in Diagnostic Laboratories?
Slow calibration drift cannot be detected from one patient's test results, but it can be identified using a control chart. Quality control (QC) is used to support result reliability and patient safety by finding problems with testing procedures as soon as possible, providing consistency of testing results across shifts, equipment, and locations, and providing evidence if a physician has concerns about a report. Laboratories are required to maintain control over the validity of their testing results under standards like ISO 15189 and the National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL) guidelines. A laboratory that can demonstrate its quality control practices will have more credibility than a laboratory that cannot.
Types of Laboratory Quality Control
Quality control internally (IQC) refers to processing control samples along with patient samples, and assessing the performance of every single processing run based upon your own data. Quality monitoring internally is broader than quality control internally, it includes monitoring of quality indicators like rejection rate, turnaround time, and report amendments. External quality assessment (EQA) or proficiency testing is when you compare your processing results with those from other laboratories via an external party. These three types of quality management provide both internal and external perspectives regarding how well you are performing.
Understanding the Three Phases of Laboratory Testing
| Phase | Example risk | Control measure |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-analytical | Mislabelled tube, wrong container, delayed transport | Patient ID checks, barcodes, collection SOPs |
| Analytical | Calibration drift, reagent lot change, instrument fault | IQC, calibration, maintenance |
| Post-analytical | Transcription error, unreviewed result, late critical call | Validation, authorisation, critical result process |
QC charts mainly watch the analytical phase, so pre- and post-analytical risks need their own checks.
Internal Quality Control (IQC): Methods and Procedures
Control materials should act similar to patient specimens and be treated in the same manner. Number of Levels: most assays utilize multiple levels of controls, generally one at or near a normal range and another that represents an abnormal condition, according to the SOP. Frequency is based on the manufacturers' recommendations, the risk associated with the assay and your SOPs for example, at the beginning of each run day and after any calibration or change in reagents.
Establish your mean and standard deviation (SD) based on your own control data. Create a Levey-Jennings chart with lines at +/- 1, +/- 2 and +/- 3 SD for each result. Evaluate the chart for sudden changes and/or gradual trends rather than simply looking at individual results. Keep track of all runs, decisions made regarding those runs, actions taken to correct issues, and who reviewed the data. Do not release patient results until quality control meets acceptable criteria. For example, if a laboratory controls for glucose with a mean of 100 mg/dL and a standard deviation of 2, a result of 107 would be outside of +3 SD, therefore the run will be rejected under 13S, patient results will be held, and an investigation will take place to determine what caused the issue.
External Quality Assessment (EQA): How It Works
In addition to the testing of patient samples, the laboratory will submit samples to the external quality assessment (EQA) program for analysis. The laboratory will then receive a report from the EQA program which compares the laboratory’s performance to either other participating laboratories (peer group) or to a target value. Each report must be reviewed by the laboratory.
If the laboratory receives a result that is outside of acceptable limits, the laboratory should determine why this occurred. For example, was there a problem with calibration? Was there a problem with the reagent used? Did someone make a typing error when entering the data? Or was there a problem with the method used? Once the reason for the poor performance has been identified, the laboratory must take corrective action and verify that the corrective action successfully resolved the issue. EQA can identify bias that may be present in the laboratory's own control systems. If no EQA program exists for a particular test, the laboratory must follow the guidelines established by its accrediting organization regarding acceptable alternatives to EQA (e.g., interlaboratory comparison).
Understanding Westgard Rules
| Rule | What it flags | Usually points to |
|---|---|---|
| 1₂s | One control beyond ±2 SD | Warning, check other rules |
| 1₃s | One control beyond ±3 SD | Random error or a large shift |
| 2₂s | Two consecutive controls beyond the same 2 SD limit | Systematic error |
| R₄s | One control above +2 SD and another below −2 SD in the same run | Random error |
| 4₁s | Four consecutive controls beyond the same 1 SD limit | Systematic error |
| 10x | Ten consecutive controls on the same side of the mean | Systematic error |
These are not universal requirements. Labs choose rules suited to each test's performance and risk, and follow their SOPs and manufacturer guidance. A common approach treats 1₂s as a warning that triggers inspection with the other rules.
NABL Quality Control Requirements in India
NABL (National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories) performs laboratory assessments based upon ISO 15189 as well as NABL's own accreditation standards, NABL 112A. This is a voluntary assessment. Assessments focus on such aspects of laboratory operation as: the quality management system the use of equipment controls, the qualifications of laboratory personnel, the use of internal quality controls (IQC) and whether the laboratory participates in proficiency testing programs or external quality assessment (EQA). According to NABL FAQs, laboratories seeking accreditation must be participating in an acceptable manner in proficiency testing/EQA for at least one year prior to applying for accreditation.
In addition to being involved in such programs, laboratories wishing to apply for accreditation must perform an internal audit and conduct a management review. Laboratories are free to develop their own validated standard operating procedures (SOPs) with regard to frequency of testing, acceptance criteria and general operational guidelines. For further information regarding these requirements, refer directly to your own validated SOPs and the most recent versions of NABL guidelines. Our article titled "A Guide To Becoming An Accredited Laboratory By NABL" provides additional details concerning the accreditation process.
Common Laboratory Quality Control Challenges
- The inconsistent control results are typically caused by problems with calibration, reagent lots or how they are stored.
- Poor documentation: QC reviewed informally, with no signature or action.
- Calibration and maintenance gaps: due dates missed.
- Reagent and inventory issues: expired kits and lot changes with no recheck.
- Manual record-keeping: charts drawn late, or not at all.
- Delayed corrective action: the same failure repeated.
- Lack of training: staff unsure which rule to apply.
Best Practices for Effective Laboratory Quality Control
- Write QC SOPs per test: materials, levels, frequency, rules, actions.
- Set limits from your own data, and review them when lots change.
- Review QC before releasing patient results, with a named reviewer.
- Record every corrective action and confirm it worked.
- Link calibration and maintenance to your QC records.
- Track trends monthly, not just failures.
- Train staff and refresh training after errors.
- Reduce pre-analytical error. See our guide to reducing sample rejection rates.
How Laboratory Management Software Supports Quality Control
Software helps in many ways first by having all record keeping in a single location, second by consistently applying the same rules to each test, third by having a clear audit trail that links the Quality Control process to the sample being tested, analyzer used to perform the test, and final report generated. Although software can assist with many aspects of Quality Control, it cannot replace well-defined Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), qualified employees performing tests, or employee judgment when making decisions regarding Quality Control. Additionally, while software may aid in obtaining laboratory accreditation, it does not guarantee it.
MargLabz is an artificial intelligence based Laboratory Operating System (OS) specifically designed for use in diagnostic laboratories. On their home page, MargLabz states that they offer 35 modules including IQC & EQAS with Westgard rule evaluations, SOPs, Corrective Actions/Preventive Actions (CAPAs) & calibration records, sample tracking through use of barcodes, analyzer interfacing capabilities, audit trails, and Turn Around Time (TAT) monitoring. They also state that their Professional Plan includes an AI Quality Control module. You can request a demonstration using your laboratory's Quality Control rules.
Laboratory Quality Control Checklist
- ☐ QC SOP exists for every test, with rules and actions
- ☐ Control materials stored and handled as specified
- ☐ QC run and reviewed before patient results are released
- ☐ Charts and limits reviewed each month
- ☐ Failures investigated and corrective actions recorded
- ☐ Calibration and maintenance up to date
- ☐ EQA enrolled for each discipline and reports reviewed
- ☐ Staff competency records current
- ☐ Reagent lots and expiry checked
- ☐ Internal audit and management review done
Conclusion
Laboratory quality control is effective when it is a standard practice: well-defined Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), daily chart review, investigation of non-conformances, serious participation in External Quality Assessment (EQA), and complete documentation. While digital systems like MargLabz can facilitate organization of these processes, the quality lies with people and their practices. To understand how digital systems can assist your laboratory with quality control, you may schedule a free demo.